After graduating high school in 2001 from Laurel Springs School, which provides homeschooling and online education, he attended American Academy of Dramatic Arts in New York City where he earned an associates degree in Fine Arts.
In 2005, he appeared in select episodes of the series Summerland, CSI: Miami and Bones. The following year, he had his first major film role in The Covenant. In 2007, he went on to star in a Feast of Love and in 2008, he appeared in select episodes of CSI: Miami. In July 2010, he played the love interest in Taylor Swift's music video "Mine". Later in 2010, he landed a minor role in Black Swan.
As of 2012, Hemingway plays a supporting role on the The Finder as Willa's gypsy cousin Timo Proud.
|2005||Bones||Tucker Pattison||Episode: "A Boy in a Tree"|
|Summerland||Jason Warner||Episode: "Signs"|
|2006||The Covenant||Reid Garwin|
|Feast of Love||Oscar|
|2008||CSI: Miami||Trey Holt||Episode: "Rock and a Hard Place|
|2011||In Time||Timekeeper Kors|
|Into the Darkness||Chase||pre-production|
|1 Out of 7||Eric|
|2012||The Finder||Timo Proud||Recurring character|
- ^ Births, Marriages & Deaths Index of England & Wales, 1916-2005.; at ancestry.com
- ^ Lindell, Kim (2007-09-28). "Ex-Ojai resident Toby Hemingway learned a lot from co-stars". Ventura County Star. Retrieved 2007-09-29.
- ^ Vena, Jocelyn (27 August 2010). "Taylor Swift Opens Up About 'Mine' Wedding Scene". MTV. Retrieved 28 August 2010.